The Amateur's Scattered Writings

Senin, 01 Februari 2021

Reflection on Hijab Coercion in Public Schools

illustration: students with hijab in schools_via flickr.com (credit: Ariel Javellana/DER/ADB)

Indonesia’s position as a democratic country with the largest Muslim majority has influenced most of its citizens. But it has been triggering a public debate when some people compelled their personal beliefs to generalize all Indonesian citizens. Furthermore, they have the authority to control others. They tend to regulate based on the principles and values adopted by certain religious groups.

A recent case came from the academic field. Jeni Cahyani Hia, a non-Muslim student in SMK N 2 Padang, West Sumatra was forced to wear a hijab. Due to that school regulation, she refused to use it. This case went viral when Jeni’s father, Elianu Hia uploaded the statement letter about their refusal on Facebook.

On that occasion, they were asked to assign the letter which included their willingness to continue this case and they waited for a decision from those who have more authority. He also shared a video containing a recorded meeting with the school. This post has been responded to by 3.6 thousand accounts, shared 3.4 thousand times, and got 5.5 thousand comments.

 

Regulations in The Name of Regional Autonomy

This viral case stems from local regulation in Padang. The city government has adopted sharia-influenced regulations. Former Mayor of Padang, Fauzi Bahar said that this regulation has been inherited for 15 years, namely, Padang Mayor Instruction Number451.442/BINSOS-iii/2005. Fauzi saw this case as a miscommunication between the student and the Principal of SMK N 2 Padang only. He made this regulation for Muslims and those who are non-Muslims, it is only an appeal not obligatory.

One of the points of instruction is that the hijab is mandatory for students studying in public schools in Padang. The regulation is aimed at Muslim students only. However, it was distorted in its implementation that non-Muslim students also wear hijab. This regional autonomy has been taken as legally which is occurs a serious political problem. At this point, the local regulations are generalized and there are no exceptions for non-Muslim students.

In addition, Padang also has local regulation (Perda) Number 6 of 2003 concerning the clever reading of the Quran for elementary and MI students. This regulation has the potential for intolerance in schools as they have a choice to wear or not wear religious attributes. They still must be treated with no discrimination and given educational services since these basic rights are guaranteed by state regulations.

Since this case blew up, Nadiem Makarim as a Minister of Education and Culture put attention to it. He mentioned this polemic has intersected with the 1945 Constitution, the Human Rights Law, the Child Protection Law, the National Education System Law, and the Ministry of Education and Culture Regulation. In his Instagram video post, he warned that Indonesia has Article 3 Paragraph 4 of the Minister of Education and Culture Regulation Number 45 of 2014 concerning uniforms for elementary and middle-level students. It was stated that the school’s basic clothes were regulated by each school and still paid attention to the rights of every citizen to practice their religious beliefs.

Referring to the existing regulation, the school cannot arbitrarily make rules or calls for students to dress not in accordance with their religion and beliefs.

 

Forcing Hijab as Symbolic Violence

The case at SMK N 2 Padang is just the tip of the iceberg of a more complex problem. There are indeed many policies that tend to be discriminatory, both in the form of instructions, appeals, to the highest level by regional regulations (Perda). The absence of protests for all this time does not mean that there’s no repression. The minority experienced the repressions but they are voiceless. This kind of repression can be known for symbolic violence.

Bourdieu defines symbolic violence as the idea where cultural and social domination takes place unconsciously in a society which includes acts of discrimination against certain groups, races, or genders. The dominant class plays its role through language which can be in the form of an obligation. The ruling class does not have sufficient access then it makes them unable to speak out. The existence of a class structure in the social formation in society is a set of networks that are systematically related to one another. It helps to determine the distribution of culture.

In this context, the city governments and the school principals have power as the dominant class who can control students through regulations. The education system has brought a whole range of cultural behavior that extends to what appears to be non-academic in nature such as how students dress up.

This phenomenon shows discrimination is getting considered normal. This is obviously more dangerous because it has become the collective consciousness of society. It becomes worse since society has normalized that the minority should follow the majority in the name of a democratic agreement.

What happened in SMK N 2 Padang brings us an opportunity that reflects there are many of us do not fully understand all of the public schools carry a mission to preserve religious diversity, culture, values, and traditions, not uniformity. Public schools are funded by a public tax of any religion. Schools, in general, must respect diversity. Every student, regardless of their religious background, must be treated equally, there can be no discrimination.

 

Sources:

https://tirto.id/rombak-peraturan-diskriminatif-wajib-jilbab-di-sekolah-sumbar-f9CC

https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5349384/eks-walkot-padang-klaim-aturan-siswi-berjilbab-cegah-iri-rambut-warna-warni

https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5345873/eks-walkot-padang-aturan-siswi-berjilbab-sudah-15-tahun-kok-baru-ribut

https://www.instagram.com/tv/CKagsK1h86h/?utm_source=ig_embed

https://www.kompas.com/edu/read/2021/01/25/194039671/p2g-kasus-seperti-smkn-2-padang-terjadi-di-banyak-sekolah?page=all

https://nasional.tempo.co/read/1426186/aturan-wajib-jilbab-di-smkn-2-padang-kemendikbud-harus-ada-sanksi/full&view=ok

http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/jurnalpartisipatoris/article/download/7790/6336

https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/151651277.pdf

1 komentar: